
Alla auktioner / Böcker, Kartor och Texter / Copy of the Author, the “Chavot Yair, ” with His Holy Signature and

Copy of the Author, the “Chavot Yair, ” with His Holy Signature and

She’elot U’Teshuvot Chut HaShani. First edition. Frankfurt, 1679. This was the first sefer printed by the renowned Gaon Rabbi Yair Chaim Bachrach, author of the Chavot Yair. The volume contains the Torah writings of three generations: responsa and novellae by his grandfather, the Gaon Rabbi Avraham Shmuel Bachrach; by his father, the Gaon Rabbi Moshe Shimshon Bachrach; and several responsa by Rabbi Yair Chaim Bachrach himself. An additional ownership inscription, (crossed out in ink but entirely legible), belonging to the renowned Gaon Rabbi Shaul Berlin, publisher of Besamim Rosh, reads: In this copy, the author removed the original leaves 23–24 that he had initially printed and pasted in their place two newly printed leaves containing a responsum he had composed. Originally, these leaves contained Responsa 19–20; in the present leaves, however, there appears the truncated conclusion of Responsum 18, an unnumbered responsum, and the beginning of Responsum 21. See the bibliographical record in the Bibliography Project for further details. Only a very small number of copies survive from the original printing. The Bar-Ilan University Library possesses an uncorrected copy, in which the omitted passages appear. See Y. S. Spiegel, HaMa’ayan, vol. 47, no. 3, Nissan 5767 [April 2007], pp. 69–76, which also includes a reproduction of the leaves from the earlier printing. (1638–1702), served as rabbi and Av Beit Din of Worms and was among the greatest scholars and halachic authorities of his generation. He studied under his father, the Gaon Rabbi Shimshon Bachrach, and the eminent Rabbi Mendel Bass, Av Beit Din of Frankfurt am Main. In 1666, he was appointed Av Beit Din of Koblenz. In 1669, he returned to Worms, where he succeeded the Gaon Rabbi Aharon Teomim as a dayan. Following the destruction of Worms in 1689, he went into exile together with the city’s Jewish community. After the Jews returned to Worms, he served as Av Beit Din of the community, succeeding his father and grandfather, until his death. Rabbi Yair Chaim Bachrach was renowned for his extraordinary erudition and mastery of all areas of Torah scholarship. He authored numerous works, most of which remained in manuscript, while others were published only in later generations. He is remembered above all for his responsa, Chavot Yair. Although he printed only a small portion of the more than six hundred responsa he had prepared for publication, the work became one of the fundamental collections of responsa and an important source for halachic decision-making. It is cited thousands of times throughout the responsa literature and is regularly quoted in the Pitchei Teshuvah. In the introduction to Chut HaShani, Rabbi Yair Chaim Bachrach lists nine works that he intended to publish. Among them was Makor Chaim on the Shulchan Aruch, which he had prepared for printing. Before he could publish it, however, the Magenei Eretz editions of the Turei Zahav and Magen Avraham appeared, arranged in a format similar to his own work, forcing him to revise it. It was eventually published only in 1982 by Machon Yerushalayim. His Chavot Yair was published by the author himself twenty years later, in 1699. Several other works have never been published. His Mar Kashisha, a work of general Talmudic principles, was published in 1993. An enormous encyclopedic work comprising forty-six volumes was lost, with only its index, Yair Netiv, surviving. Rabbi Shaul Berlin (1740–1795), son of Rabbi Tzvi Hirsch Levin, Chief Rabbi of London and later of Berlin, remains one of the most fascinating and controversial rabbinic figures of his generation. A tremendous Torah scholar, Ordained as a rabbi at a young age, and at the age of 28, he was appointed rabbi of Frankfurt an der Oder. He later withdrew from the rabbinate and moved to Berlin, where his father served as rabbi. He published polemical pamphlets containing criticisms of the Birkei Yosef of the Chida and of the works of Rabbi Raphael Hakohen of Hamburg. These publications provoked a major controversy and led to bans and condemnations against their author. In 1793, Rabbi Shaul published the responsa collection Besamim Rosh. According to his account, the sefer contained responsa of the Rosh and other early authorities, collected by a scholar named Rabbi Yitzchak de Molina, who had lived in the time of the Beit Yosef and had himself added glosses to the work. Shaul appended his own commentary, entitled Kisei DeHarsena. The sefer received the approbation of his father Rabbi Tzvi Hirsh, who praised him profusely. The sefer also contains a letter by the Noda BiYehuda, who extols the virtues of the author and describes him as a Torah leader whose novellae don’t need an approbatio Immediately upon its publication, however, a fierce controversy erupted over the work, with opponents claiming that it was a forgery and that the responsa had not been authored by the Rosh or any of the early authorities, but were in fact composed by Shaul Berlin himself. Rabbi Shaul’s responsa and commentaries contain numerous unusual passages and leniencies that appear contrary to traditional halachic practice, including various permissions concerning yayin nesekh, traveling on Shabbat, alterations to synagogue practices, shaving during Chol HaMoed, and arguments advocating changes to Torah commandments for various reasons. Several of the leading scholars of the generation publicly denounced the work. Among its most prominent opponents were Rabbi Mordechai Bennet and the Chatam Sofer, who famously referred to it as “the falsehoods of the Rosh” (Kazvei HaRosh). R. Shaul’s father, R. Tzvi Hirsch Levin Rabbi of Berlin, refused to accept the contentions of those who questioned the book, and even published a special work in which he valiantly defends his son (Ish Anav, Berlin 1793) The controversy surrounding Besamim Rosh continued for generations, particularly over whether the entire work was fabricated or whether genuine earlier material had been altered by an outside hand. While many leading halachic authorities rejected the work entirely, others quoted passages from it and engaged with its contents. Its status remains disputed to this day: some authorities avoid it altogether, while others make cautious use of it without regarding it as an authoritative source from the period of the Rishonim. According to virtually all knowledgeable authorities, however, the work is regarded as a forgery, internally and externally. [1], 92, 95–115 leaves. 18 cm. book
Utropspris:40 402,46 SEK
Till auktionenVisa alla föremål frånAppel Auction HouseellerBöcker, Kartor och Texter
Utropspris:
40 402,46 SEK
Liknande föremål
Slutpriser för liknande föremål
KARTA, "Des Royaumes Suede, de Norwege et de Danemark", Paris, 1821
11/16/2026
450 SEK
Uppsk.: 1 000 SEK
SUN TZU, Militäravhandlingen "krigets konst" (sun zi bing fa), skrift
11/16/2026
2 300 SEK
Uppsk.: 800 SEK
GEORGE BUCHANAN, SKOTTLAND, (1506-82). "Baptistes, siue calumnia
11/16/2026
22 355 SEK
Uppsk.: 2 000 SEK
PUBLIUS TERENTIUS AFER. "Eivsdem Mvreti argvmenta et scholia in singvlas
11/16/2026
1 300 SEK
Uppsk.: 1 200 SEK
Nå samlare över hela världen med din auktion!
Lista er auktion








